We regularly talk to tax agents and taxpayers about whether they have documents to prove their tax position. Sometimes we discuss what that might look like, what documents are available, and how well they think they can do this; other times gener.al assurances are given and the discussion moves on.
These discussions came to mind when reading QKPW and C of T [2026] ARTA 2614. It tells a tale spanning ten years where the Commissioner continues pursuing an individual, what the individual could prove (and the efforts they went through to do it) and shows that the standard one has to meet to win is high. Very high. Even when the requirement is only on the balance of probability. It also shows what the ATO will do in its attempts to discredit a taxpayer to make it harder for that taxpayer to succeed.
The case
The case related to an individual who was an Australian whose career was mainly conducted overseas. He lived in Monaco from 1983 until he returned to Australia in September 2012. By then he had sold his business and had been diagnosed with a serious illness. This illness was the reason he and his wife returned to Australia. Whilst the tax case continued, the individual died before the case was heard in late 2025.
The individual was a merchant banker. During the nearly 30 years he lived in Monaco he had set up various business and investment structures. These structures appear to have been domiciled in the British Virgin Islands and at least one of them had mixed use (i.e. it acted as nominee to hold assets for the individual and also for clients of his business). Around the time he returned to Australia, the ownership of entities and various investments were put into the name of a discretionary trust controlled by him and his wife.
From FY2013 the trust and both individuals filed Australian tax returns. The ATO commenced a review of his affairs in November 2016 as a result of him being linked with parties who were mentioned in the Panama Papers. The review was escalated to an audit, and covered FY2007 to FY2016. This audit continued until a position paper was issued in late 2020. That paper contemplated increasing the individual’s taxable income for each of FY2013 to FY2017 mainly in respect to:
- Revenue from various foreign investment entities (about $1.4m per full year); and
- Transferor trust income (i.e. income that went to a trust which the ATO said should be assessed to him) (about $270K per full year).
Overall the additional tax liability raised was $3.645m. The ATO said that evasion had occurred due to the amount it said was payable, due to him having access to professional advice but not adequately seeking it, that because he was a merchant banker he was a sophisticated taxpayer with a history of using offshore structures and that the structures were multilayered ones located in secrecy jurisdictions. The ATO also argued he had given evasive answers and failed to keep adequate and proper records.
Penalties were also imposed on the basis that there has been intentional disregard of the law with a 20% uplift (due to alleged withholding of information from the ATO), being a total of a 90% penalty.
Whilst an objection was lodged, the ATO dismissed it.
From the above, clearly the taxpayer had a challenge if he was going to try to succeed on appeal. He accepted that challenge. Over 13,000 pages were lodged with the Tribunal by both parties. The ATO’s reasons for the amended assessments alone appear to have been over 900 pages long before including the annexures.
Ultimately the taxpayer was successful in relation to the foreign investment entity income as he was able to prove that the investments were held for others and not held for him, but was unsuccessful in relation to the transferor trust income. He also succeeded in reducing the penalty rate slightly to 80%.
Burden of proof
Under self-assessment, the burden of proof is entirely on the taxpayer. So the taxpayer has to show that on the balance of probabilities the ATO is wrong and also prove their correct taxable income. In this case it appears that the taxpayer sought to prove the correctness of every line item in their tax return, including items already declared in their original returns. Where the ATO had obtained information which it said showed that the taxpayer had involvement in various investments he obtained more specific evidence that he was not so involved. He also undertook an exhaustive search and identified omissions such as a $416 capital gain arising from the foreign currency conversion rules in one year, and an undeclared capital loss made in an earlier year.
The taxpayer also undertook an asset betterment calculation (this was because the amended assessments were raised under s.167, rather than the usual s.170) showing his asset level on return to Australia, significant income and expenditure amounts since then and linked these to AUSTRAC reports. Taking all of this into account, the ART decided it was just enough to be sufficient to show that the ATO had not made its case on the $1.4m annual income amounts.
The taxpayer could not meet the burden of proof for the other income, seemingly because the third parties involved in the transfer trust did not wish to become involved in the case, which hampered his ability to prove his case.
ATO’s arguments re character of the taxpayer
As noted, the taxpayer died after the ART case commenced, but before the hearing itself. Thus he was not available to be a witness or to be cross-examined. As his illness progressed he did offer to be examined via written questions from the ATO, which was declined. After he had died the ATO tried to characterise the taxpayer as ‘false’ and ‘willing to mislead’, which the taxpayer could no longer personally defend against. The ATO also sought to have the Tribunal give little or no weight to Witness Statements by the taxpayer due to them being unable to be tested under cross-examination. It was however noted by the Tribunal that comments made by the Commissioner in the Penalties Position Paper “were somewhat eyebrow-raising” (para 194).
The ATO also brought up a long list of other matters which it argued were blameworthy. The Tribunal devoted 1710 words to set out the arguments made by the ATO in relation to these acts (paras 171- 173). Many were trivial, with one being a directorship held for one day in 1993 which was not declared, on which the Tribunal said “I agree with the Applicant’s submissions that this suggestion is complete pedantry. It is surprising to see it raised at all, as the Commissioner can do better than this.” The tenor of the ATO’s arguments appears to be that any taxpayer error is blameworthy and thus can justify a finding of evasion. Such an approach leaves no room for a simple error, and is hard to reconcile with the ATO Charter, where the ATO says “Our relationship with you is based on mutual trust and respect. We are committed to being fair, ethical and accountable in everything we do.” To us, examples such as the one above gives an impression that the ATO was trying to ‘win at all costs’ and hadn’t considered whether its behaviour was fair or ethical.
Conclusion
For anyone who wishes to read it, this is a very long judgement – 232 paragraphs plus 788 footnotes. The costs for both the taxpayer and the ATO would have been very significant. There are many things one can take from it. On the one hand, being linked to people named in the Panama Papers invites very significant ATO scrutiny. On the other, living overseas for 30 years whilst creating and building a business is going to result in overseas entities and there is nothing sinister in that.
The main takeaway for me is that this taxpayer went to significant effort and provided an enormous number of documents and even then only barely met the burden of proof on the argument he won, but was unsuccessful on the other aspect which also meant that the evasion aspect was upheld. So please pause and think before you assume that you and your client have enough to prove your position when challenged by the ATO.
We regularly talk to tax agents and taxpayers about whether they have documents to prove their tax position. Sometimes we discuss what that might look like, what documents are available, and how well they think they can do this; other times gener.al assurances are given and the discussion moves on.
These discussions came to mind when reading QKPW and C of T [2026] ARTA 2614. It tells a tale spanning ten years where the Commissioner continues pursuing an individual, what the individual could prove (and the efforts they went through to do it) and shows that the standard one has to meet to win is high. Very high. Even when the requirement is only on the balance of probability. It also shows what the ATO will do in its attempts to discredit a taxpayer to make it harder for that taxpayer to succeed.
The case
The case related to an individual who was an Australian whose career was mainly conducted overseas. He lived in Monaco from 1983 until he returned to Australia in September 2012. By then he had sold his business and had been diagnosed with a serious illness. This illness was the reason he and his wife returned to Australia. Whilst the tax case continued, the individual died before the case was heard in late 2025.
The individual was a merchant banker. During the nearly 30 years he lived in Monaco he had set up various business and investment structures. These structures appear to have been domiciled in the British Virgin Islands and at least one of them had mixed use (i.e. it acted as nominee to hold assets for the individual and also for clients of his business). Around the time he returned to Australia, the ownership of entities and various investments were put into the name of a discretionary trust controlled by him and his wife.
From FY2013 the trust and both individuals filed Australian tax returns. The ATO commenced a review of his affairs in November 2016 as a result of him being linked with parties who were mentioned in the Panama Papers. The review was escalated to an audit, and covered FY2007 to FY2016. This audit continued until a position paper was issued in late 2020. That paper contemplated increasing the individual’s taxable income for each of FY2013 to FY2017 mainly in respect to:
- Revenue from various foreign investment entities (about $1.4m per full year); and
- Transferor trust income (i.e. income that went to a trust which the ATO said should be assessed to him) (about $270K per full year).
Overall, the additional tax liability raised was $3.645m. The ATO said that evasion had occurred due to the amount it said was payable, due to him having access to professional advice but not adequately seeking it, that because he was a merchant banker he was a sophisticated taxpayer with a history of using offshore structures and that the structures were multilayered ones located in secrecy jurisdictions. The ATO also argued he had given evasive answers and failed to keep adequate and proper records.
Penalties were also imposed on the basis that there has been intentional disregard of the law with a 20% uplift (due to alleged withholding of information from the ATO), being a total of a 90% penalty.
Whilst an objection was lodged, the ATO dismissed it.
From the above, clearly the taxpayer had a challenge if he was going to try to succeed on appeal. He accepted that challenge. Over 13,000 pages were lodged with the Tribunal by both parties. The ATO’s reasons for the amended assessments alone appear to have been over 900 pages long before including the annexures.
Ultimately the taxpayer was successful in relation to the foreign investment entity income as he was able to prove that the investments were held for others and not held for him, but was unsuccessful in relation to the transferor trust income. He also succeeded in reducing the penalty rate slightly to 80%.
Burden of proof
Under self-assessment, the burden of proof is entirely on the taxpayer. So the taxpayer has to show that on the balance of probabilities the ATO is wrong and also prove their correct taxable income. In this case it appears that the taxpayer sought to prove the correctness of every line item in their tax return, including items already declared in their original returns. Where the ATO had obtained information which it said showed that the taxpayer had involvement in various investments he obtained more specific evidence that he was not so involved. He also undertook an exhaustive search and identified omissions such as a $416 capital gain arising from the foreign currency conversion rules in one year, and an undeclared capital loss made in an earlier year.
The taxpayer also undertook an asset betterment calculation (this was because the amended assessments were raised under s.167, rather than the usual s.170) showing his asset level on return to Australia, significant income and expenditure amounts since then and linked these to AUSTRAC reports. Taking all of this into account, the ART decided it was just enough to be sufficient to show that the ATO had not made its case on the $1.4m annual income amounts.
The taxpayer could not meet the burden of proof for the other income, seemingly because the third parties involved in the transfer trust did not wish to become involved in the case, which hampered his ability to prove his case.
ATO’s arguments re character of the taxpayer
As noted, the taxpayer died after the ART case commenced, but before the hearing itself. Thus he was not available to be a witness or to be cross-examined. As his illness progressed he did offer to be examined via written questions from the ATO, which was declined. After he had died the ATO tried to characterise the taxpayer as ‘false’ and ‘willing to mislead’, which the taxpayer could no longer personally defend against. The ATO also sought to have the Tribunal give little or no weight to Witness Statements by the taxpayer due to them being unable to be tested under cross-examination. It was however noted by the Tribunal that comments made by the Commissioner in the Penalties Position Paper “were somewhat eyebrow-raising” (para 194).
The ATO also brought up a long list of other matters which it argued were blameworthy. The Tribunal devoted 1710 words to set out the arguments made by the ATO in relation to these acts (paras 171- 173). Many were trivial, with one being a directorship held for one day in 1993 which was not declared, on which the Tribunal said “I agree with the Applicant’s submissions that this suggestion is complete pedantry. It is surprising to see it raised at all, as the Commissioner can do better than this.” The tenor of the ATO’s arguments appears to be that any taxpayer error is blameworthy and thus can justify a finding of evasion. Such an approach leaves no room for a simple error, and is hard to reconcile with the ATO Charter, where the ATO says “Our relationship with you is based on mutual trust and respect. We are committed to being fair, ethical and accountable in everything we do.” To us, examples such as the one above gives an impression that the ATO was trying to ‘win at all costs’ and hadn’t considered whether its behaviour was fair or ethical.
Conclusion
For anyone who wishes to read it, this is a very long judgement – 232 paragraphs plus 788 footnotes. The costs for both the taxpayer and the ATO would have been very significant. There are many things one can take from it. On the one hand, being linked to people named in the Panama Papers invites very significant ATO scrutiny. On the other, living overseas for 30 years whilst creating and building a business is going to result in overseas entities and there is nothing sinister in that.
The main takeaway for me is that this taxpayer went to significant effort and provided an enormous number of documents and even then only barely met the burden of proof on the argument he won, but was unsuccessful on the other aspect which also meant that the evasion aspect was upheld. So please pause and think before you assume that you and your client have enough to prove your position when challenged by the ATO.
—– –
![]()